Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny

Dec.02.2025
Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny
Canadian outlet Rebel News released a long-form video report examining Canada’s regulatory framework for nicotine pouches, market dynamics, and the approval process of ZONNIC, a product of BAT subsidiary Imperial Tobacco Canada. The report highlights issues involving youth access, regulatory gaps, black-market activity, retailer feedback, and company responses. This article summarizes key points based on the video.

Editor’s Note:Imperial Tobacco Canada, mentioned in this report, is not affiliated with Imperial Brands. It is a wholly-owned subsidiary of British American Tobacco (BAT), and all tobacco-related sales, brand operations, and distribution activities in Canada are carried out as part of the BAT Group.

 


 

Key Points

 

  • Nicotine pouches entered the Canadian market around 2020 with no approval requirements, no prohibition, and no age restriction.

 

  • A 2020 federal memo classified them as drugs but still did not restrict sales to minors.

 

  • ZONNIC, produced by Imperial Tobacco Canada, was approved in 2023 and became the only nicotine pouch legally sold on the open market.

 

  • The Health Minister accused companies of “exploiting loopholes” and issued new rules in 2024 limiting flavors to mint and requiring pharmacy-only sales, though still without a legal age ban.

 

  • Retailers report they cannot sell nicotine pouches legally while black-market products continue to circulate.

 


 

2Firsts,December 2, 2025——Canadian media outlet Rebel News released a roughly 30-minute video examining the regulatory status of nicotine pouches in Canada, their market availability, and the full approval process of ZONNIC, a product sold by Imperial Tobacco Canada, a BAT subsidiary. The report covers youth access, regulatory gaps, black-market distribution, retailer observations, and company responses.

 

Below is a summary organized by 2Firsts based on the video.

 

 

1. Entry of Nicotine Pouches into Canada and Early Regulatory Conditions

 

 

According to the video, nicotine pouches contain nicotine but no tobacco and are used by placing them under the upper lip. Health risks were not yet fully understood, though some smokers used them as alternatives.

 

Around 2020, nicotine pouches entered Canada through imports and online channels, featuring various flavors, nicotine strengths, and packaging styles. At that time, they were neither authorized nor prohibited, and there was no legal age restriction.

 

A federal memo issued in November 2020 classified nicotine pouches as drugs:

 

  • Under 4 mg: could be classified as Natural Health Products (NHPs)
  • Above 4 mg: could fall under prescription drug requirements
  • Health risks had not yet been assessed

 

The video notes that even after this memo, no prohibition on sales to minors was implemented.

 

Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny
The Canadian Department of Health issued a public warning in 2020, stating that unauthorized oral nicotine pouches may pose serious health risks. | Image Source: Rebel News

 

 

2. ZONNIC Approved in 2023, Becomes the Only Legally Marketed Product

 

 

The video reports that Imperial Tobacco Canada submitted its application around 2021.


In October 2023, Health Canada granted approval for ZONNIC (4 mg) to be marketed as a Nicotine Replacement Therapy (NRT).

 

Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny
The video pointed out that Imperial Tobacco Canada released a press release on October 12, 2023, announcing that its nicotine pouch product ZONNIC has been approved by Health Canada. | Screenshot from Rebel News video

 

Several health groups simultaneously called for stricter controls on flavors, packaging, nicotine levels, and retail channels, emphasizing ease of youth access.

 

Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny
ZONNIC | Screenshot from Rebel News video

 

 

3. Health Minister’s Public Criticism and the 2024 Supplementary Rules

 

 

The video presents several statements by then–Health Minister Mark Holland, including:

 

  • Allegations that companies used flavors and packaging appealing to youth
  • Claims that companies were “using loopholes” to get products approved
  • Several forceful remarks demanding companies “stay away from kids”

 

Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny
Translation: Former Canadian Minister of Health Mark Holland | Screenshot from Rebel News video

 

In 2024, the Minister issued Supplementary Rules on Nicotine Replacement Therapies, which included:

  • Required NRT-specific labeling
  • Prohibition of brand elements considered appealing to youth
  • Only mint flavor permitted
  • Pharmacy-only or pharmacist-supervised sales; no self-selection
  • Mandatory “18+” labeling
  • Still no legal prohibition on selling to minors

 

Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny
Official document cover of the "Supplementary Rules Respecting Nicotine Replacement Therapies Order" released by Canada in 2024 | Screenshot from Rebel News video.

 

 

4. Company Response: Approval Process and Market Context

 

 

In the interview, Imperial Tobacco Canada’s VP of Corporate and Regulatory Affairs responded to several points:

 

(1) Approval Process
The product went through a two-year review, consistent with other NRTs.

 

(2) On the “loophole” accusation
He stated packaging and flavoring complied with NRT requirements and that the company followed the formal approval pathway.

 

(3) User Feedback
The company had received feedback from adult smokers reporting that ZONNIC assisted them in quitting.

 

(4) Number of Legal Products
He confirmed that ZONNIC was the only nicotine pouch legally sold at the time and noted that another pouch product had been approved but not yet launched.

 

(5) Cigarette Sales Changes
The video shows that some stores experienced declining cigarette sales before the new rules, followed by increases afterward.

 

Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny
Translation: Vice President of Corporate and Regulatory Affairs Eric Gagnon of Imperial Tobacco Canada Company interviewed | Screenshot from Rebel News video

 

 

5. Retailer Feedback, Black-Market Activity, and Tax-Stamp Issues

 

Interviews with vape shop and cigar shop owners highlighted:

 

  • Retailers cannot legally sell nicotine pouches despite strong customer demand
  • ID checks are performed for consumers who appear under 30
  • Vape shops face strict limits on signage, displays, and advertising
  • Retailers reported unclear responses from Health Canada regarding regulatory questions

 

Canadian Media Investigation: BAT’s Nicotine Pouch ZONNIC Sparks Ongoing Controversy as Regulatory Gaps in Canada Come Under Scrutiny
Vape Vault owner Steven Rothenburger displays the supply of nicotine products in local retail channels during an interview with Rebel News. | Screenshot from Rebel News video.

 

The video also shows that unauthorized pouches continued circulating online and through informal channels, sometimes with higher nicotine levels or counterfeit packaging.

 

In Alberta, the introduction of a provincial tax stamp in addition to the federal stamp forced retailers to clear older inventory. One retailer reported disposing of CAD 11,650.75 worth of products, and had heard of other stores incurring even larger losses.

 

The video concludes by noting that Health Canada had not responded to media inquiries and mentions an online petition.

 

We welcome news tips, article submissions, interview requests, or comments on this piece.

Please contact us at info@2firsts.com, or reach out to Alan Zhao, CEO of 2Firsts, on LinkedIn


Notice

1.  This article is intended solely for professional research purposes related to industry, technology, and policy. Any references to brands or products are made purely for objective description and do not constitute any form of endorsement, recommendation, or promotion by 2Firsts.

2.  The use of nicotine-containing products — including, but not limited to, cigarettes, e-cigarettes, nicotine pouchand heated tobacco products — carries significant health risks. Users are responsible for complying with all applicable laws and regulations in their respective jurisdictions.

3.  This article is not intended to serve as the basis for any investment decisions or financial advice. 2Firsts assumes no direct or indirect liability for any inaccuracies or errors in the content.

4.  Access to this article is strictly prohibited for individuals below the legal age in their jurisdiction.

 

Copyright

 

This article is either an original work created by 2Firsts or a reproduction from third-party sources with proper attribution. All copyrights and usage rights belong to 2Firsts or the original content provider. Unauthorized reproduction, distribution, or any other form of unauthorized use by any individual or organization is strictly prohibited. Violators will be held legally accountable.

For copyright-related inquiries, please contact: info@2firsts.com

 

AI Assistance Disclaimer

 

This article may have been enhanced using AI tools to improve translation and editorial efficiency. However, due to technical limitations, inaccuracies may occur. Readers are encouraged to refer to the cited sources for the most accurate information.

We welcome any corrections or feedback. Please contact us at: info@2firsts.com

New York’s 75% Wholesale Tax on Nicotine Pouches Takes Effect Sept. 1, With Aug. 31 Inventory Subject to Floor Tax
New York’s 75% Wholesale Tax on Nicotine Pouches Takes Effect Sept. 1, With Aug. 31 Inventory Subject to Floor Tax
New York State will extend its tobacco products tax to “alternative nicotine products,” including tobacco-free nicotine pouches, from September 1, 2026, at a rate of 75% of the wholesale price. Distributors, wholesalers and retailers must also inventory products held as of 11:59 p.m. on August 31 and pay a floor tax. Vapor products are excluded from the new category and remain subject to New York's separate 20% supplemental sales tax on the retail price.
Aug.26
Haypp Report Shows Nicotine Pouches Gaining Ground as a Vape Alternative in the UK
Haypp Report Shows Nicotine Pouches Gaining Ground as a Vape Alternative in the UK
According to Haypp’s 2026 UK Nicotine Report, nicotine pouches are increasingly replacing both cigarettes and vaping. The UK market grew sharply, with Haypp and Northerner reporting a 60% year‑on‑year sales increase in 2025. Notably, 40% of users adopted pouches to quit vaping, nearly matching the 43% who used them to stop smoking. This indicates pouches are expanding beyond traditional smoking cessation and gaining traction among adults seeking non‑inhalable nicotine alternatives.
Jul.01
Changing Assumptions in U.S. Cigar Consumption: 2Firsts Interviews Cigar Educator Mechelle Merkerson
Changing Assumptions in U.S. Cigar Consumption: 2Firsts Interviews Cigar Educator Mechelle Merkerson
U.S. premium cigar culture is shifting toward education, broader choice and deeper links to craftsmanship and origin, cigar educator Mechelle Merkerson told 2Firsts. She sees boutique brands, women consumers and production-region experiences making knowledge central to cigar participation. For global brands, retailers and emerging markets such as China, education may help turn curiosity into sustained engagement.
Special Report
Jul.06
Shopify Requires Merchants to Remove All Vape Products by July 8, Reshaping Online Sales Channels
Shopify Requires Merchants to Remove All Vape Products by July 8, Reshaping Online Sales Channels
Shopify has instructed merchants using its web-hosting services to remove vape products from their online stores by July 8, 2026. The policy expands beyond illegal products and applies to all electronic nicotine delivery systems (ENDS), marking a broader shift in online platform oversight of nicotine sales.
Innovation
Jul.14 by 2Firsts Perspectives
JAMA Issues First U.S. Clinical Guidance on Vaping for Smoking Cessation, Urging Complete Switch From Cigarettes
JAMA Issues First U.S. Clinical Guidance on Vaping for Smoking Cessation, Urging Complete Switch From Cigarettes
JAMA has published a Special Communication offering systematic recommendations for U.S.-based clinicians on the use of nicotine e-cigarettes in adult smoking cessation. Developed by the Harm Reduction Workgroup of the Society for Research on Nicotine and Tobacco’s Treatment Research Network, the paper recommends including e-cigarettes alongside FDA-approved cessation medications in risk-benefit discussions. It cites high-certainty evidence that nicotine e-cigarettes achieve higher quit rates than nicotine replacement therapy and evidence suggesting efficacy comparable to highly effective medications such as varenicline and cytisine. For adults who choose vaping to quit, the authors recommend FDA-authorized products, sufficient nicotine delivery and a rapid, complete transition away from cigarettes rather than prolonged dual use.
Aug.13
2Firsts Exclusive Analysis | RLX Q2 Revenue Rises 14.8%, Company Takes Control of Western European Distributor and Expands Multi-Category Strategy
2Firsts Exclusive Analysis | RLX Q2 Revenue Rises 14.8%, Company Takes Control of Western European Distributor and Expands Multi-Category Strategy
business accounting for 68.5% of sales. A new controlling investment in a Western European distributor and plans to scale modern oral nicotine pouches point to a broader international strategy spanning channels and multiple product categories.
Special Report
Aug.14