PMI Responds to 'Why is PMI Still Selling Cigarettes': Stopping Sales Is Not the Solution, Driving Consumer Transformation Is Key

Nov.28.2024
PMI Responds to 'Why is PMI Still Selling Cigarettes': Stopping Sales Is Not the Solution, Driving Consumer Transformation Is Key
PMI recently addressed the ongoing controversy regarding its continued sale of cigarettes on LinkedIn, emphasizing that achieving a smoke-free future requires reducing demand for cigarettes rather than an outright ban. The company's Chief Communications Officer said that simply halting cigarette sales will not solve the demand issue but will instead drive the market toward illegal trade or other brands.

Recently, Philip Morris International (PMI) addressed the long-standing question on LinkedIn: "Why is PMI still selling cigarettes?" In its response, PMI emphasized that achieving a smoke-free future requires a gradual reduction in cigarette demand, rather than an immediate ban.

 

The company outlined three key reasons:

 

  • Consumer Behavior Takes Time to Change: PMI's goal is to encourage adults who have not yet quit smoking to switch to smoke-free alternatives. This shift in consumer behavior takes time. The company emphasized that without this change, an outright ban on cigarettes would not solve the issue. Consumers could turn to competing brands or the illegal market, complicating efforts to control smoking.

 

  • Legal Restrictions Limit Product Diversification: In some countries, current laws only allow the sale of traditional tobacco products (such as cigarettes and cigars). These legal constraints hinder PMI's ability to promote smoke-free products, delaying progress toward a smoke-free future.

 

  • Balancing Shareholder Responsibility: As a publicly traded company, PMI must balance shareholder interests while ensuring sustainable growth. The company is gradually transitioning away from the cigarette business, but abruptly discontinuing a successful product line would be unrealistic and detrimental to long-term success.

 

 

Executive Response: Reducing Demand is Key


 

PMI's Chief Communications Officer, Dr. Moira Gilchrist, emphasized in a video that simply halting cigarette sales will not eliminate market demand.

 

PMI Responds to 'Why is PMI Still Selling Cigarettes': Stopping Sales Is Not the Solution, Driving Consumer Transformation Is Key
PMI Chief Communications Officer Dr. Moira Gilchrist

 

"Philip Morris International unilaterally stopping to sell cigarettes tomorrow won't change a thing. Our transformation makes sense because what we're working on is reducing the demand for cigarettes over the long term," Dr. Moira Gilchrist said.

 

Dr. Moira Gilchrist emphasized that the key action is to gradually reduce cigarette demand over the long term, rather than abruptly halting production. She noted that when she joined PMI in 2006, the company's revenue was entirely derived from cigarette sales. Since then, PMI has gradually reduced its reliance on cigarettes and has been actively promoting the development of smoke-free products.

 

"Fast forward to now and all people need to do is look at the published data. Many people have been somewhat surprised by our transformation and the pace of change."

 

Opinion | As EU Reviews Tobacco Rules, Experts Warn Against Overlooking Smokers’ Alternatives
Opinion | As EU Reviews Tobacco Rules, Experts Warn Against Overlooking Smokers’ Alternatives
As the European Commission reviews its tobacco and advertising rules, two experts who provided written comments to 2Firsts argue that future EU policy should not overlook adult smokers’ alternatives. Dr Garrett McGovern and Dr Carmen Escrig say regulators should weigh relative risk, adult switching, flavours, consumer behaviour and scientific uncertainty alongside youth protection.
Industry Insight
Jun.01
Malaysia Nicotine Vape Market Faces Legal Uncertainty Over Tax and Poisons List Ruling
Malaysia Nicotine Vape Market Faces Legal Uncertainty Over Tax and Poisons List Ruling
Malaysia’s Finance Minister Anwar Ibrahim said duties and taxes on nicotine-containing vape products will be determined in line with the Court of Appeal’s ruling on whether liquid or gel nicotine can be exempted from the Poisons List under the Poisons Act 1952, a case that could affect the legal basis for vape taxation, retail sales and future ban policy.
Jun.29
U.S. Senator Durbin Criticizes FDA’s First Flavored Vape Authorization, Says Trump Administration Conceded to Big Tobacco
U.S. Senator Durbin Criticizes FDA’s First Flavored Vape Authorization, Says Trump Administration Conceded to Big Tobacco
U.S. Senator Dick Durbin on May 13 criticized the Trump Administration’s Food and Drug Administration for approving the sale and marketing of fruit-flavored e-cigarettes for the first time, while also allowing some illegal vaping products to remain on the market. He also linked the regulatory shift to the departure of FDA Commissioner Marty Makary, saying White House pressure on regulators to approve tobacco product applications could create serious public-health consequences.
Regulations
May.15
Altria Reports Q1 2026 Net Revenues of $5.43 Billion and 7.3% Growth in Adjusted Diluted EPS
Altria Reports Q1 2026 Net Revenues of $5.43 Billion and 7.3% Growth in Adjusted Diluted EPS
Altria Group reported its first-quarter 2026 results on April 30. Net revenues were $5.43 billion, up 3.2% year on year, while revenues net of excise taxes were $4.76 billion, up 5.3%. Reported diluted EPS was $1.30, up more than 100%, and adjusted diluted EPS was $1.32, up 7.3%.
May.06 by 2FIRSTS.ai
Canada Vape Enforcement Action Puts VAPME Website, Trademark and China Supply-Chain Links in Focus
Canada Vape Enforcement Action Puts VAPME Website, Trademark and China Supply-Chain Links in Focus
Quebec police seized about 300,000 suspected illegal vape products and froze more than C$1.8 million in funds. Local media said vapme.ca, a website selling flavoured vape products, was shut down during the operation.
Regulations
Jun.18
Indonesia to Step Up Vape Surveillance as Concerns Rise Over Drug-Laced E-Cigarettes
Indonesia to Step Up Vape Surveillance as Concerns Rise Over Drug-Laced E-Cigarettes
Indonesia will strengthen surveillance of vapes amid growing concerns over drug-laced e-cigarettes. The National Food and Drug Monitoring Agency, or BPOM, will soon take charge of monitoring nationwide vape distribution and said it will work with the National Narcotics Agency, or BNN. BNN recently floated a plan to completely ban e-cigarettes, saying a total ban was the only way to prevent liquid narcotics.
May.11 by 2FIRSTS.ai